My opinion is that the funny titles tend to cause people to post "Totally Useless Posts" just to get their numbers, and egos built up.
The icons, however, seem to be a good way to put some emotion into your post. Face it, text just doesn't convey emotions very well. Icons could be used with different facial expressions that would help to convey the tone of the post.
One thing I enjoy about POP forums as opposed to UBB is the minimal formatting and special effects features offered. When people start using bold and italics, and different colors and font sizes and styles, and adding images and such, it really slows down reading the forum and can make it annoying or hard to read.
POP version 4 adds the much needed navigational tools and makes it very easy to use.
Content is favorable to looks and special effects.
-------------
----
David Bowers
Mayor, Coasterville