MBP Hurricane, why is it so rough?

Monday, January 28, 2002 12:20 PM
Everyone always talks about how smooth CCIs are, and I agree 100%. But is this coaster an exception? The first year I rode it in 2000 it wasn't as rough, but in 2001, it was terrible.

Is it the steel support structure? Unlike wooden supports which obsorb the shock, does the steel not obsorb the shock as well?

Is it rough because of the Gerstlauer trains? Many complain about Gerstlauer trains but are they really the problem?

Even though we can complain about so many other rough woodies. The reason for those are braking. But this is a tough one to decipher due to barely any trims.

Give your thoughts and opinions.

-----------------

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 12:27 PM
A simple solution to the roughness is to ride in the front, everywhere else gives me a headache in the helices. The front is as smooth as all the other CCIs

-----------------
Is there somthing more, then what I've been handed, I've been crawling in the dark looking for the answers!- Hoobastank

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 12:29 PM
Steel supports should have nothing to do with it.  Plenty of CCIs with steel are perfectly smooth for a woodie.  Perhaps maintanence has something to do with it?  If you give a wood coaster some TLC it will stay great!
-----------------
- Peabody

*** This post was edited by Peabody on 1/28/2002. ***

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 12:34 PM
The ride was actually smoother in the front. Thank goodness for the seat dividers though! That ride, no matter where you sit whips you around quite violently!
-----------------

*** This post was edited by WCS4488 on 1/28/2002. ***

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 12:37 PM
The Hurricane has seat dividers?   I thought the G-Trains didn't have them.
-----------------
"Prejudice does no service to you. Break the shackles it's up to you" - Stereolab "Our Trinitone Blast"
+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 12:38 PM
No, i'm pretty sure that it does, but can someone clear this up for me?
-----------------
-Visit my website whenever I get it up!
+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 1:18 PM
One reason...G-Trains. ;)
-----------------
Flying High Again.

*** This post was edited by Ozzyhead on 1/28/2002. ***

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 1:28 PM
Actually Villian has Gerstlauers and (mostly) everyone seems to think of it as one heck of a great ride.
-----------------
-Visit my website whenever I get it up!
+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 2:25 PM
So some G-trains have dividers? My only experience is The Legend, and I didn't really consider the "bump" between the seats to be a divider, as I was flying from side to side during a solo ride. :)
+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 4:35 PM
The "G trains" as you call them do not have seat dividers, but do have a sort of bucket seat to them, where the sides of the individual seat are raised.

-----------------
Jes
Webmaster, Jes's Roller Coasters
"Thank You Jeff Putz" "My Fellow Americans, Lets Roll!"

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 5:05 PM
maybe it has something being near the ocean, i know there are tons of other woodies near oceans, but maybe there is something in the air through there, because the swamp fox is the roughest woodie(or coaster) i have ever been on and its about 5 blocks from the hurricane, i actually gave my friend a bloody nose on it because i had my hands up and they hit him in the nose
+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 5:13 PM

P>'ve been on a few coasters with G-Trains, Villain, Legend, and Twisted Sisters, and must say... these trains are some of the worst out there.  Now to see if its actually the track or the trains still remains to be seen.  But solid proof will come once Holiday World opens and Legend runs with PTCs.  Only then we will know if it is the G-Trains that are the problem./P>
P>FONT style="BACKGROUND-COLOR: #ffffff">Coasterman Mike - who wants to start a petition to ban G-Trains for CCs/P>
-----------------
Now, a card carrying member of ACE.
Total rides on Pittfall: 255
Total rides on Superman:UE : 633
+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 8:15 PM
For me, the "problem" with G-trains arises when the layout produces significant laterals...Villain I had NO problems with, but the layout provides airtime (and plenty of it), not lateral forces.  Legend ran perfect through the airtime sections IMO, but had some trouble in the double-helix (gotta wonder if Jeff H. agrees with me on that, LOL).  TS, honestly, ran SO slow and screechy I couldn't even feel any forces at all, so I can't speak as to how the trains would run on greased track at decent speed. 

But, on to the real comparison:  Cheetah!  The Gerstlauer-train, CCI, steel-supported woodie, that I have logged considerable time on.  And know, my analysis: 1) CCI builds great coasters...as if you didn't know.   2) CCI woodies on steel supports run better through the air hills then through tight twists and helices (based on Lola, Stella, and Cheetah).  and 3) Although G-trains get a lot of bashing, I think they're fine on out-n-backs, they just don't function as well on twister-type layouts...

I'd love to ride this coaster so I can do more "analysis"...LOL.

-----------------
Off-season coaster blues got you down, stop by the 'buzz and turn your frown upside-down...
Son of Drop Zone - PKI CoasterCamp I Champions!!!

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 8:32 PM

WCS4488 said:
Everyone always talks about how smooth CCIs are, and I agree 100%. But is this coaster an exception? The first year I rode it in 2000 it wasn't as rough, but in 2001, it was terrible.
Is it the steel support structure? Unlike wooden supports which obsorb the shock, does the steel not obsorb the shock as well?
Is it rough because of the Gerstlauer trains? Many complain about Gerstlauer trains but are they really the problem?
Even though we can complain about so many other rough woodies. The reason for those are braking. But this is a tough one to decipher due to barely any trims.
Give your thoughts and opinions.
-----------------

Depends on what you are describing as rough.   I think the G trains track far better than PTC's even though Rideman would say Its all the same running gear, It is not.  One train has tapered roller bearings and one has round and a few other minor differences.  I also think the G trains roll with far less friction.
Now for the rough.  My brother rode it in august and said it wasn't rough but one of the helixes it just whiped you about and was hard to maintain a upright possition.  As we are a Insane coaster loving duo, My brother ranked it as his third favorite woodie.
 I have been on several steel and a few wood framed CCI's and I think the wooden framed ones vibrate more.  Legend last season was getting a wicked vibration on the bottom of the first drop (Being Replaced by Jeff H!).   I thought the figure eight on Cheetah might be to some to be too intense but I loved it!   It was interesting that while talking to a PR rep at Wild Adventures that he said in the summer the figure eight  somtimes has to be inspected several times a day for excessive Track Pin Shear!
Chuck, who considers Cheetah his number 4 and has never ridden a CCI he considers rough.  Rough is the backseat of Skyliner!

-----------------
Charles Nungester
Park Jockey :)

+0
Monday, January 28, 2002 8:35 PM

DrachenFire04 said:
maybe it has something being near the ocean, i know there are tons of other woodies near oceans, but maybe there is something in the air through there, because the swamp fox is the roughest woodie(or coaster) i have ever been on and its about 5 blocks from the hurricane, i actually gave my friend a bloody nose on it because i had my hands up and they hit him in the nose

Now we are considering bodily inflicted wounds and rough? :)
Chuck, just kidding!

-----------------
Charles Nungester
Park Jockey :)

+0
Tuesday, January 29, 2002 2:08 AM

because the swamp fox is the roughest woodie(or coaster) i have ever been on and its about 5 blocks from the hurricane, i actually gave my friend a bloody nose on it because i had my hands up and they hit him in the nose

That's interesting, I found Swamp Fox to be very smooth (unless you count my back slamming into the seat after the ejector air :P) and one of my favorite wooden coasters. As for Hurricane, the Gerties definitely make it a bit rougher, and there are some easy to tell 'kinks' in the track, especially in the last helix. I enjoyed it anyway :)

-------------
|| Jonathan Hawkins ||
http://www.starcoasters.com
http://www.thrillspot.com

+0
Tuesday, January 29, 2002 4:14 AM
The g-trains on Villain tore me apart, and I am not one to complain about roughness on coasters.
+0
Tuesday, January 29, 2002 4:42 AM
To me, the worst spots are in the helices.  When I last rode it in the fall, there seems to be some roughness in the first turn of the first helix.  Its not too bad.  The worst is that nasty jolt coming out of the last helix.  No matter where you're sitting, it just kills the ride and it quite painful.  I've actually heard people go OWW! while riding it!  I don't know if they've done any retracking on the coaster during the off season.  I was down there a few weeks ago and didn't see any signs of any.  About that nasty jolt in the last helix, I heard that it was the result of some retracking gone bad.  I hope it gets fixed because that second helix is my favourite part of the ride.

Max

-----------------
"For millions of years mankind lived just like animals
Then something happened which unleashed the powers of our imagination
We learned to talk."----Pink Floyd-"Keep Talking"

+0
Tuesday, January 29, 2002 5:46 AM
The hills are pretty smooth except for the straitaway beforen the first helix, it feels like the poured gravel all over ther track in that spot. The 2 helixes gave me bruises on my thighs after 35 laps.
-------------
"This Movie spent way to much money on special effects, look they couldnt even afford to buy those little dudes shoes!"
+0
Tuesday, January 29, 2002 5:52 AM
joey isch, any woodie that DOESN'T give you bruises after 35(!) laps wasn't worth riding in the first place.  I mean, c'mon, 35 laps is a riding marathon on a woodie....
-----------------
PoTP acolyte - remove fear to reply
Son of Drop Zone - PKI CoasterCamp I Champions!!!
+0

You must be logged in to post

POP Forums - ©2018, POP World Media, LLC
Loading...