Goose,
The Beast may be overrated to some folks but it's still a major draw for me. That's the reason why I went down there this past summer. Not for Sonny, but for Papa. But being a fellow Ohioan as yourself, you can get to PKI anytime. It's only a three and a half hour drive down I-71 to get there.
SFGAm, on the other hand, wins hands down. Though I think Racer at PKI is much better than American Eagle, the park has a good assortment of thrill rides. Raging Bull simply rules with Viper a very close second. Add in Batman, Giant Drop, the cool light tunnel on Demon, the theming of the entire park (especially Southwest Territory and Hometown Square) and a larger variety of food, SFGAm is the place to go.
-------------
SFWOA: An Unofficial Guide
http://sfohio.tripod.com