I've noticed in all of these posts the confussion between the system in place at other parks, and the one at SF. Problem is that the systems (note I say systems, not system) in place at the SF parks is different at all of them. What happends is that as people describe the system in place at a given park, it may look like they are not telling it correctly.
So, I believe that right there is SF biggest problem. Not all the parks have the same system.
I will agree with what Jeff said about the Disney System. For one, its free. Another good plus about it is that you don't stand in line physically while you wait for your time to ride. What I mean by that is that if you go and get your ticket at 11 AM, and your ride is set for 6 PM, between 11 and 6 you are not in line, but enter the line at 6 PM, then wait to ride.
This kind of system to me works the best for these reasons:
1) Its FREE
2) Everyone that goes to the park has the same
right and chance to get these tickets. In fact, (please correct me if I'm wrong here), to get one of the Disney Pass systems, all you do is put your admission ticket into some kind of machine, and it spits our your ride time on a ticket. Each person that goes to Disney has a ticket, and can use this system any time they want.
3) Since everyone that gets in line at their required time is required to walk the line, there is no "line jumping" going on. You stand in line like you would before the system was in place, except everyone knowns what time they need to get in line. This makes everyone feel they are "equal" to each other, and there is no special treatment
going on here.
Now, compair that to the SFGAm FastPass System. Notice I said SFGAm, since again, every SF park has a different system. The one at SFGAm costs you $10, and they only sell a limited number of tickets each day. You are limited when you can enter the line. I believe at SFGAm they are only valid between 11 AM and 8 or 9 PM, and they are only valid for the day you purchase them. But, you can ride anytime during that time frame. But, unlike the Disney system, the Fast Pass lines at SFGAm are not the only line into the ride....yes they are shorter, but you enter the normal line at a given point and then "line jump" in front of people who have not paid the extra $10, and who have already been waiting for a chance to ride.
People have said that $10 is not that bad for 4 or 5 rides without the wait. Here's the problem...if a family of 5 goes to SFGAm on their vacation (lets assume that all people pay the normal gate admission). Check out how much money this will cost them:
Parking: $10
Admission: $199.95 (5 * 39.95)
Total: $209.95.
Now, each person wants a fast pass ticket. That's 5 fast passes, at $10 each. So, add another $50 to that total, and your up to $259.95. Add now since these people are on Vacation, they will eat in the park for at least 2 meals, and buy stuff. This family of 5 will probably spend well over $500 dollas at the park. I don't know of many people who will be willing to shell out $50 more on top of what they already are spending for a day at the park on their vacation. (Not to mention that since they are on Vacation, they have probably got a hotel somewhere, have paid to travel to the park either by car or by plane, paid for driving on the tollway in Illinois, etc, etc.) The cost does add up quickly.
I do agree that if the fast pass systems at the SF parks are set up EXACTLY like the Disney Systems, then they would be a good idea. Any variation from what Disney does is not a good idea in my book. If the problem is that Disney won't allow other parks to "copy their system, with no varriation", then I believe the only choice for the SF parks is not to have one. Disney did a good job on their system. Either do it the Disney way, or don't do it at all.
--Brian
-------------
Brian A. Plencner
E-Mail: saurses@home.com