The negatives you describes are exactly the same as what they're trying at IOA.
Go here if you wanna read some threads.
http://64.225.125.24/forums/forumdisplay.php?s=&forumid=30 At IOA they have Express Pass. It's basically the same thing, except you get the tickets from a Kiosk machine, then hand each one to a guard.
You go thru a seperate line, then merge with the regular queue. Yeah, you get dirty looks from people. And it slows down the regular line to a crawl. I'm not a big fan of it. When you have the tickets, it's great. But imagine a father who brings his family (wife and 2 teenagers). He'll have to shell out 40 extra dollars, otherwise they'll end up waiting in slower lines. At least they're only giving out 2000 of these cards.
It's the wrong solution. The answer is to build more attractions, and have early opening hours so the real fans can get more rides before the GP arrives.
-------------
Robin Fox - "I see Stars, Can You See Them Too?"