Posted
A miniature train at a South Carolina park derailed and overturned on Saturday, killing a 6-year-old child and injuring at least 18 other people, authorities said. The train at Cleveland Park in Spartanburg had 28 people on board when it derailed. The state admits that its inspector falsified a report certifying it for use, as it was not operational when he performed the inspection.
Read more from MSNBC.
See video from AP:
This sounds oddly familiar in a bad way:
http://www.lostindiana.net/Lost_Indiana/Lost_Indiana__Old_Indiana_Fun_Park.html
I think that depends. The inspector may not bare as much responsibility barring any information that because of his failed inspection something allowed the train to go faster (which I doubt). It seems like from what the article said that the guy driving intentionally was driving too fast (in which case I still don't think it's like the Dells accident), but perhaps that wasn't communicated correctly.
Maybe he meant that he realized the train was going to fast and then the accident happened.
I dunno. Likely from what the article said, he was intentionally driving too fast. In that instance, he put people's lives at danger. I have to wonder if he had to undergo any training to drive that particular train.
Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened.
jhitesma said:
This sounds oddly familiar in a bad way:http://www.lostindiana.net/Lost_Indiana/Lost_Indiana__Old_Indiana_Fun_Park.html
That's the first thing that came to my mind, too. Simple train ride passes inspection wrongly, then was operated poorly. It's such an unnecessary situation to end up with.
I've read a copy of the Police report, and while yes he said that he was going to fast, if you take what the reporting officer put down in their report as what he said verbatim, then I wonder whether or not he was in shock. If that was the case then what he said can't be taken as the truth totally. I'd hazard a guess that there is a whole lot more to this tragic incident than just what has hit the media so far.
I've been searching for the POV video mentioned in the above post with no luck. Does anyone want to supply a link?
This is just terrible. Who would think that an accident on a small miniature train would cause so many injuries and even a death?
Is there a chance that the speeding was a malfunction? My first car did that once when the gas pedal got stuck.
-Travis
www.youtube.com/TSVisits
I'd be careful about using the video too much to analyze the speed of the train. The video is in many regards really jumpy and hard to get a perspective from. It does seem a bit faster than many trains run, but then again, I've seen some run faster as well (i.e. ever riddle the train at Knobels?) It's further biased by the close nature of fence to the train, making it appear as if you are in a tunnel essentially. A speed might be calculated based on some of the objects.
My suspicion is there is a set of problems that developed. Possibly a bit excess speed, coupled with a car rocking a bit too much, coupled with a random dip in the track or possibly a kink in the track brought on by sun heating or settling of the trackbed. Remember a train is not like a roller-coaster in that the track is relatively free to move and does move A LOT. This, coupled with potentially a downgrade section (I do not know the layout) and maybe a slight mechanical delay int eh brakes applying when trying to slow unfortunately resulted in a tragic situation. We'll need to wait for the final report to come out to know exactly what happened (if even then...)
Walt S said:
My suspicion is there is a set of problems that developed. Possibly a bit excess speed, coupled with a car rocking a bit too much, coupled with a random dip in the track or possibly a kink in the track brought on by sun heating or settling of the trackbed. Remember a train is not like a roller-coaster in that the track is relatively free to move and does move A LOT. This, coupled with potentially a downgrade section (I do not know the layout) and maybe a slight mechanical delay int eh brakes applying when trying to slow unfortunately resulted in a tragic situation. We'll need to wait for the final report to come out to know exactly what happened (if even then...)
Everything in your long list could be summed up by saying the train was going too fast, seeing as how that's the only variable the operator has any control over.
Brandon | Facebook
Read this. Interesting that the general media didn't pick this up.
You must be logged in to post